The Most Confused Bagel Shop You’ve Ever Loved

We are a curbside business - It started with covid and then we grew out of space to allow customers inside. We miss your faces but curbside works for us. Ordering happens online at eatbxj.com or the link below. You can order in person however orders are always fired in the order in which they come in, for faster service we highly suggest using the online ordering.

The fastest way to reach us is via text at 973.780.4740 - please note this is a text only number, we don’t take calls on it.

Learn more about our 3 different daily menus below

We’re open Thursday-Sunday 8a-730p. We are also now open Mondays from 11am-7p with 1 all day menu. For Thursday-Sunday we operate 3 different meal services during those. Please keep in mind pizza is available all day

8a-1p “Breakfast and Lunch” Bagels, breakfast specials and sandwiches, lunch specials, pizza and more

1p-4p “Happy Hour” - Triple deckers, pizzas, hot subs, burger sliders, wings, cheese steaks and other specials

4p-730p “Dinner” - Primarily Italian (all pastas are made in house) with other daily specials as well as triple deckers, hot subs, wings and more.

Click here to order - make sure to set your pickup time in order to see the correct menu for your time

a boutique bagelry with a backstory.

It’s a story about a man who developed his own bagel recipe and decided to share them with neighbors when he had extras. The news of the elusive “Jarrett bagel” spread like wildfire and the town demanded a place to buy them. What makes them so special? Jarrett is a man of excess, and his bagels don’t escape that. One bake is not enough; he double bakes. A few seeds will not do; he seeds both sides until it’s coated through and through. But Jarrett is also a man of heart, and food is always 100% better when it’s made with love, so you’d better believe that the passion is infused throughout the bagel. Or is that the good ole West Orange water? Maybe it’s both.